Technology and Work
By the early 20th century engineering was
triumphant--Americans looked to rationality and efficiency to make life
better. More, faster, better was the theme of the time.
But questions
began to be raised. Cowan ch. 8 is important for its discussion
of
the impact of technological change on the experience of work.
Back to the history of Mass Production:
The Assembly Line:
- Once the American System of Manufacture had
speeded
up the making of individual parts, the next critical problem was the
assembly process
- prehistory--the most often cited example is
in
hog butchering (a disassembly line)
- In 1906
Henry Ford recognized the potential market for a light, powerful,
low-cost car, and
demand for the Model-T quickly outstripped supply when production
started
in 1908 (more about this
later in the unit on the automobile)
- Ford built a new factory with craneways
between
buildings and sequentially arranged special-purpose machine tools (and
hand
trucks)
- Seeking to take this a step further Ford
decided
to try a moving conveyor belt, first for magnetos in 1913, then all
over
the plant by 1915. Reduced assembly time from 12 1/2 man-hours to
5
5/6.
- The economies of scale for the model-T were
overwhelming--lasted until 1927, some 15 million were built.
Ford's River
Rouge
Plant
Charlie Chaplin's
Modern Times shows fears that the assembly line would make men into
machines.
Scientific management :
- Frederick
Winslow Taylor
--proper Philadelphian who went to work for a machine shop with the
idea
of working his way to the top.
- he was appalled by how inefficient the
workers
were and set out to rationalize them.
- In 1895 he introduced the differential piece
rate--you got a lower rate if you worked slower.
- Taylor wanted not just to reward the worker
but
to tell him how to do the job--time studies. Also introduced high speed
tool
steel and patented improved metal cutting machines. (Taylor's
classic book is available on the web at:
The Principles of Scientific Management )
- Frank
B. Gilbreth
, who joined Taylor in 1907, extended this to motion study--watching
how
the worker moved and showing him how to eliminate waste motion
- his partner and wife,
Lillian Gilbreth
, realized that worker resistance was still a key issue and pioneered
industrial
psychology (they also had 12 children and raised them efficiently, as
chronicled
in Cheaper by the Dozen)
- Scientific management was applied to skilled
workers, not just workers on assembly lines
a machine
used
today in evaluation of workers
How did workers feel about all this?
- Ford's workers were initially not happy with
the
assembly line initially--turnover reached 380%
- Starting in 1914 Ford paid twice the going
wage,
and found people eager to work under those terms
- Taylor thought his system would help
workers, but
they hated the lack of control, and in some cases went out on strike
against time study (such
political agitation that in 1915 Congress outlawed Taylorism at
government arsenals)
- skilled workers were loosing their position
to
unskilled workers with machines:
- Cowan gives the example of carpenters
using factory-made components
- new office machines revolutionized the
office work
force--in 1870 men made up 97.5% of the clerical labor force. But
typewriting became a
women's job
. By 1890 women were 21% of clerical labor force, by 1920
50%.
Some even argued that women were better with machines than
men.
- Pride in work (my list is based on Cowan p.
187):
- relatively high wages
- work that is not mind-numbingly repetitive
- some control over daily schedule
- some control over quantity and quality of
what
is produced
- some job security because of time it would
take
to train a replacement
There were other people besides workers who had
doubts:
- World
War I
showed the dangers of more efficient weapons.
- The
conservation movement worried that we would run out of resources.
- some people in the 1920s feared that
traditional
values were being lost, which is why the first major protests over the
teaching of Darwin happened then (see
Scopes Monkey Trial )
- The
Great Depression of the 1930s made those doubts a lot more common,
because a lot of the problem
was overproduction.
this page written and ©
Pamela E. Mack
last updated 10/14/05