Nye Introduction
David
Nye
Nye does NOT assume that:
- progress inevitably means using more and more
energy
- more energy is better
- technology determines history
- the path of technological change is
inevitable
- the particular impact of technology on
society is inevitable
But he does see technological momentum as an issue: power
systems are not easy to change
why do the United States and Canada use more energy per
capita than any other nation?
Nye argues against technological determinism:
- some people see technology as inevitable, or progressing
so rapidly that society cannot keep up
- Nye argues "Human beings select the machines the use and
shape them to fit within different cultures." (p. 3)
Social construction of technology:
- "social forces control the invention, adoption and
development of machines and systems" (p. 3)
- which technology wins is not just about which machine is
better but about which fits the needs of society
- however it is not easy to change the shape of established
systems
- they are maintained by society: just because of
investment in infrastructure--consider changing driving side
- those big systems eventually lose momentum
- but they survive a long time, embedded in society
- what seems natural to us is whatever system was in place
when we were a child, but it isn't natural
What shaped the energy system in the US?
- overlapping systems: muscle power, water power, steam,
electricity, internal combustion engines
- the role of workers and managers in shaping technological
systems
- changing life patterns (urbanization) and culture of
consumption