The Enlightenment, Natural Theology, and Romantic
Nature
Ideas about nature first
started to
change in the late 1700s and more clearly in the
1800s. Europeans began to admire (from a
distance) the wilderness in North America and a few
Americans who lived
in
cities picked up this idea (actually settlers on the
frontier still saw
wilderness simply as something to be conquered).
Both the Enlightenment and the people who reacted against it
(Romantics) developed more positive views of
wilderness. The idea
that wilderness was good was spreading, but it took several
different
forms.
The Enlightenment was an intellectual movement in the 18th
century. The scientific
revolution got people excited that we can
understand the world through science. This led to an
emphasis on
finding better ways of doing things, instead of
tradition. This
was very influential on the American revolution and the
constitution.
New ways of seeing nature
resulted from the enlightenment, in three
rather contradictory ways.
the enlightenment
led some
intellectuals to Deism:
an
approach to religion that focuses on God
as the creator of
the world, rather than emphasizing God intervening in
our daily lives
(and if you focus on God as creator then the creation
becomes an
important way of knowing God). God is a perfect
watchmaker who
made the creation work so well that God doesn't need to
interfere.
the development of
science
led to the idea of natural
theology, a different approach that lead to the
idea that
studying nature was a way to
get closer to God, popular even among some evangelicals
The Romantic movement
in
Europe was a reaction against the idea that science can
explain everything, that everything is rational.
It led to an
enthusiasm for whatever was wild and
mysterious. God is in the mysterious and can't be
understood so
is a very personal experience.
Where did this new idea--Natural
Theology--come from?
Science started
out in
conflict with religion at the time of the scientific
revolution
Galileo was the
first to
use experiment to gain scientific knowledge--can
show by an experiment
that Aristotle is wrong--experience trumps authority
Copernicus
published the
theory that the earth goes around the sun, fifty
years later Galileo
found evidence to support it
got in trouble
with
church
over whether the Copernican theory contradicted the
bible
"Tell it out among the
nations:
"The LORD is King!
he has made the world so firm that it cannot be
moved;" (Psalm
96:10)
Galileo
tried to explain another passage, in which God told
the
sun to stand still (Joshua 10:12-14) in order to
make the day
longer. But if the length of the day is caused
by the earth's
rotation then telling the sun to stand still won't
make the day
longer. Galileo explained that God was telling
the sun to stand
still so both sun and earth would stop
rotating.
Galileo got in
trouble
for coming up with his own interpretation of the
Bible
first Galileo
forbidden
to teach
the Copernican theory, then confined to house arrest
and required to
abjure the theory
is the source of
truth
authority (Bible and teachings of church) or
experience (experiment)
despite these
early
conflicts between science and religion, as science
became more and
more successful, people began to look for ways to put
the two together
the development of
science
made people more interested in nature and showed the
natural world to
be complex and impressive
this led to the
idea that
studying science was a way to admire the handiwork of
God
one argument they
used is
if you discover a watch the
best explanation is that there must be a watchmaker (William
Paley)
more emphasis on
the idea
that we learn more about God by studying the wonderful
things he
created--these people tended to believe that the more
science they
studied the better Christians they would be
Hitchcock
(gravestone below) was a professor of geology (and
then president) of
Amherst College and a Congregationalist minister
believed that
everything he
could learn as a scientist would support his religious
beliefs
people believed
they could
come closer to God both by reading the Bible and by
knowing better the
glorious works of the creator--the book of nature as
it was before
human beings tamed it
+
Romanticism:
A
literary and artistic movement that encouraged an
interest in the strange, remote, solitary, and
mysterious, instead of wanting to make the world as
well-ordered as
possible.
Romantics didn't
want to
understand everything rationally, they were interested
in what couldn't
be understood
Romantics weren't
sure that
civilization had indeed
made us happier, but instead admired primitive people
they were more
interested
in feelings and imagination and less interested in
rationality
they saw feelings
as wild and identified rationality with civilization
they were interested
in
those things that cannot be understood rationally
Romanticism was a fad--not
many
people believed it fully
but
Romantics popularized several ideas that were more widely
influential
they had a new idea of how
nature
is beautiful
Sublime: natural beauty
that was
not neat and well-ordered like a garden but complex,
uncontrollable and
impressive,
leading to feelings of awe.
beauty that changes
the
viewer, that brings the viewer in touch with God or some
greater truth
experiencing nature
creates
awe for God's creation and becomes a form of worship
An emphasis on the
individual character of different nations (romantic
nationalism)
Europeans admired American
scenery before
Americans did. Romantics gave everybody new words to
use to
describe their experience of nature.
Copying European ideas, a few Americans
began to write of wilderness as
beautiful. This was new--it seems obvious to us
but people
really hadn't written about it that way before.