Rothman ch. 1
"Within
two
decades of the end of World War II, nearly everything about
American life had been altered." (p. 7)
"Americans wanted more, and they wanted it faster"
How completely new was the dramatic change in public opinion
on
environmental issues in the 1960s?
- it was in some ways
a
continuation of the conservation movement
- increase in role of
government, particularly government regulation
- concerns about
pollution
and environmental degradation were growing even before
1960, but they
begin to be addressed more on a federal level
- in other ways it was
radically new--questioning
progress, wider
concern for nature for nature's sake
Progressive Movement
and pre-WWII
conservation
- the Sierra Club was
founded in
1892 by Muir but also by important people like the
president of
Stanford University
- the Progressive
Era (early 20th
century) was a time of reform--cleaning up corruption and
dirty cities
- big cities had become
corrupt
places, there were no laws to protect people injured on
the job or to
protect consumers from dangerous products
- cleaning up corruption
often
included cleaning up pollution and trash that companies
could get away
with under the corrupt city governments
- people began to believe
that the
government should take responsibility for protecting the
weak and
consumers
- settlement house
movement--community groups trying to help the poor, Mary
McDowell
- early history of regulation
- The traditional belief was that
ordinary
people could and should watch out for themselves
(buyer beware), but as
consumer goods came to be made far away instead of
locally and
technology became more complex that didn't work so
well any more.
- employees had no right to
compensation for
accidents from their employers because of a legal
principle called
"fellow servant"
- The progressive movement around 1900
led to
the first regulations. Anti-trust regulations
around 1900 and the Pure Food
and Drug Act (1906). Workers compensation
started in
the 1910s.
- so that is how government regulation
started
- Progressives wanted to replace
corruption with
efficiency and professionalism--not just help the poor
but use social
science to find out the best way to do so
- experts know best (an idea that has
been
slowly declining since the late 1970s)
- they tended to
think they
knew what was best for everyone else
- the conservation
movement
in the first half of the 20th century was tied in with
the Progressive
movement
- emphasis on
letting the
experts decide
- relatively small
group of
people who wanted to make things better
- protecting special
places
and animals
Progressive
idea about protecting the weak members of society led to
a new belief
in government regulation, including of pollution
Progressive
movement (early 20th century)>>New Deal (1930s)
expansion of
government role>>WWII experience of the power of
science and
technology
After WWII the factories were quickly converted to
make consumer goods (unlike after
WWI there was an economic downturn when the demand for
war materials
disappeared)
- for example,
factories
making radar sets were quickly converted to make TV
sets--a technology
ready to take off
- returning
veterans had new
opportunities--they got help with college tuition
and expenses and then
help with mortgages
- many people had
money to
spend and they wanted more consumer goods
- they felt at
first their
dream was being realized--their own house and car,
new things like
television, life was good
Post World
War II transformation--a lot
more people started caring about environmental issues,
particularly
those that affected them where they lived.
- wealth--they
could afford
to care
- suburban
movement--what
people valued in the places where they lived changed
- wealth meant
more products
therefore more factories and more pollution
At first focused on
things that smelled bad and on parks
Suburbs
- Cities were growing very fast.
Between
1870 and 1920 New York City expanded
from less than a million to 5 1/2 million
population. Density
increased in the center
city with the invention of the elevator and steel frame
construction.
- New York grew larger in size as
well--from 22
to
almost 300 square miles.
- Urban services--particularly handling
garbage
and sewage and providing water--had a hard time keeping
up.
The progressives planned new expanded systems.
- The
first suburban explosion resulted from streetcars.
People lived
in row houses (townhouses) within walking distance of a
trolley stop
- The Progressives invented urban
planning. By about 1910 they had the ideas of a
central business
district, zoning, a system of parks and parkways, and
planning roads to
allow circulation--including the first limited access
highways.
These plans were very successful--the value of central
property went up
and therefore the tax base.
- Automobile based suburbs were growing
even
before WWII
- What did middle class people
want?--safety,
uniformity, yards, etc.
- The automobile corresponded with
American
values on independence and privacy.
- To get this people were willing to
move
further and further out. In the 1920s Los
Angeles opened 3200
subdivisions
After World War II there
was
another step:
- prosperity--many new
technologies (such as TV) and people were rich enough to
buy them
(partly because the GI bill allowed many soldiers to go
to college)
- huge growth in
suburbs and
a high value put on family life and where you
lived--people
increasingly wanted their own home with a yard
- After the war many
returning soldiers married and started families and
wanted to own a
home--new suburbs were built even more rapidly
- Farmland became
housing
developments
- Planned towns--
Levittowns (first
in 1949). Only in 1960s were proposals for
cluster zoning to
leave open space successful.
- Identical houses could be built
rapidly
from standardized parts
- The attached garage replaced the
front
porch, and large lots allowed space-wasting one
story ranch houses.
- Suburbs
were very segregated, not just by race but by income
level and often
ethnicity (red-lining), also further separated the
world of men and
women.
- people who wanted suburban life
believed
that they had a right to quality of life--that is
what they expected to
find in suburbs
- suburbs caused some environmental
problems
such as automobile pollution
Traffic in Los Angeles, 1949
Environmental impact of postwar
prosperity:
- by the late
1950s there
began to be questioning of the suburban dream--you
could have a nice
house and life somehow still seemed empty
- people moved to
the suburbs
to have nature around them and that was disappearing
- for the first
time there
began to be a shortage of wood as so many new wooden
homes were built
(led to more cutting in National Forests)
- many more people
commuting
by car (plus goods transported by truck) meant
increased demand for fuel
- whole new cities
had grown
up around wartime manufacturing
- prewar
approaches to
pollution by simply diluting it (eg. by dumping it
in a river) didn't
work as well any more
- the Cuyahoga
River in
Cleveland caught fire
Gasoline ( petroleum history
sites
)
- People first thought
the automobile would clean up the city--compared to
horse manure and dead
horses
- Automobile created a whole new industry
to
provide fuel. Automobiles run on gasoline, a
relatively
light fraction
of
crude oil. Diesel fuel (which is essentially the
same as
home heating oil) is a relatively heavy fraction.
- The heaviest fractions (bitumen or rock
asphalt) had been used for centuries for waterproofing
and after 1800
for roads. Kerosene was used in lamps from the
1850s.
- In 1859 an American industrialist, George
H.
Bissell began a deliberate search for oil.
They chose a
site in Pennsylvania, drilled through 70 feet of
bedrock, and used the
oil from the well for illuminating gas, lubricating oil,
and an
excellent lamp oil. Within 15 years
production in the
Pennsylvania field had reached 10 million (360 lb)
barrels a year.
- John D. Rockefeller established
Standard
Oil in 1870. By building a pipeline system he soon
gained
control of 90% of a rapidly-growing industry and became
for a while the
richest person in the world.
Beginnings of the Petroleum Industry
early oil refinery
- The oil was distilled to separate the
fractions--first gasoline (1.5 to 15 percent, depending
on the crude),
which at first was a nuisance because it was highly
inflammable and had
no use, then kerosene, and then lubricating
oil. For a good
explanation of refining see Modern
Refining.
- With the popularity of the automobile
suddenly
gasoline was in greater demand than the other fractions,
and cracking
was invented by William Burton at Standard Oil in
1913. Heavier
fractions are converted into lighter ones by subjecting
them to high
temperature and pressure to break down the chains of
carbon atoms into
shorter ones. Industrial research labs competed to
find more
efficient ways
of doing this, most important catalytic
cracking with a platinum catalyst in the 1920s.
- problem of engine knock arose just
before WWI
as refineries tried to widen the cut. Solved by
the 1922
introduction of tetraethyl lead as a fuel
additive. To prevent
lead from fouling the engine ethylene dibromide was
added to react with
the lead residue and make sure it was funneled out of
the exhaust
system into the atmosphere (at the time the only
questions raised were
about hazards of the lead to refinery workers).
- why didn't they think this was
dangerous--because the hazardous material would be
diluted by the
atmosphere
- Industry fought evidence of the health
hazards
of lead
- leaded gasoline was phased out starting
in the
1970s because the lead that got into the atmosphere and
fell into the
soil in heavily traveled areas was identified as a
significant cause of
lead poisoning.
chart from ehw.org
People began to realize that
pollution was
hurting them.
The new Conservation
- a new emphasis on
wilderness
- organizations like
the
Sierra Club and the Wilderness society only slowly
became willing to
fight, to play confrontational politics
It wasn't easy to
challenge
established institutions
- the Forest Service
was too
much influenced by the companies that cut timber in
National Forests
- the Park Service was
in the
tourist business
- the Bureau of
Reclamation
was in the dam building business
- those dams provided
the
water for the growth of cities like Los Angeles and
Phoenix
Efficiency was still the
dominant
value