Cronon 4
http://www.todayifoundout.com/index.php/2014/08/land-much-really-right/
what does it mean to own land?
- rights, protection, responsibility (such as
to pay taxes)
- it is yours, you should be able to do what
you want
- rights, protects responsibilities shift over
time
A owns B and the society give A certain rights to
control B and sanction people who violates those rights
ownership and sovereignty are different things
Indian leaders had power by kin networks and earning respect
(and gift exchange), not by organized government
- alliances and the scale of organization
varied according to need
- but groups as embodied in their leaders did
have customary rights to areas of land that could be
traded
- these are more like sovereign rights than
ownership
- often it was only some rights that were given
up
Other kinds of ownership
- Individuals did own personal property such as clothing
and tools
- they weren't very oriented towards accumulating goods and
tended to give away what they didn't need
- individual families had the right to land they were
farming and living on, but that wasn't a permanent right, only
while they were using it
- what could be traded was the right to the use and product
of the land (usufruct rights)
- permanent tools like weirs might belong to a kin group
- no rights were owned to very plentiful things like
migratory birds, but traps were owned
- ownership was not of the land but of its products
The English applied their own definitions of ownership,
which the Indians did not understand
- The English had several different forms of land
ownership, with different responsibilities to the king
- the king claimed the land and the organizers of a colony
granted it to groups of settlers to form towns
- land was divided among families according to what they
could farm
- that land ownership was permanent and transferable, but
rights were limited and included rights to meadows and
woodlots, sometimes as common land, as well as farmland
- defining land primarily by its boundaries was a new idea
developed by the European settlers
To what extent were colonial towns a market society?